Cracks are beginning to show in Toronto. While the Maple Leafs organization outwardly projects a united front, a closer look reveals potential discord between star center Auston Matthews and head coach Craig Berube. The team's inconsistent performance has amplified existing tensions, raising questions about the long-term alignment of the team's best player and its bench boss.
Berube's arrival was initially met with optimism. After Sheldon Keefe's firing in May 2024, the organization sought a "new voice" to propel the team further in the playoffs. Keith Pelley, President of Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment (MLSE), suggested that a lack of chemistry with Keefe was a significant factor in the coaching change. Berube, known for his direct, no-nonsense approach, was seen as the ideal candidate to instill a tougher, more disciplined culture.
However, Berube's "grind-first philosophy," which emphasizes relentless intensity, seems to be causing friction with Matthews. While Matthews remains an elite player, his "instinctive scoring touch" has not been as consistent, leading to increased scrutiny. Berube has publicly challenged Matthews to "reset his game" and elevate his overall performance. Following a loss to Edmonton, Berube called out his leadership group, further intensifying the pressure.
Matthews, for his part, has acknowledged the need for improvement across the team. He stated that "we can all be better" and emphasized the responsibility of leaders to elevate their play, particularly in close games. Matthews' response, delivered after a practice session, was measured and focused on accountability. However, some observers have noted a "drop in energy and engagement" from Matthews since the coaching change, fueling speculation about a potential disconnect.
The timing of these tensions is particularly concerning. With the Maple Leafs currently outside the playoff picture, every game carries significant weight. The pressure to win is mounting, and any signs of internal strife are quickly magnified. Recent reports suggest that the possibility of trading Matthews, once unthinkable, is now being discussed more openly. While trading a team captain in his prime is "not standard practice," the organization faces a difficult decision if the current dynamic persists.
Dave Rosehill has gone so far as to accuse some Leafs players of trying to get Berube fired. While he defended Berube and his coaching style, he made it clear that he believes the players' lack of effort is unacceptable.
Ultimately, the success of the Maple Leafs hinges on the ability of Matthews and Berube to find common ground. Whether they can bridge this gap and align their visions remains to be seen. The coming months will be critical in determining the future of both Matthews in Toronto and the team's Stanley Cup aspirations.
