The Edmonton Oilers are facing tough questions after benching forwards Andrew Mangiapane and Trent Frederic, representing over $7 million in offseason investments, during Tuesday night's game against the Nashville Predators. This decision is a stark admission that the team's plans have gone awry as they struggle to meet Stanley Cup expectations.
Mangiapane, acquired to bolster the team's offensive capabilities, finds himself on the outside looking in, with a trade potentially on the horizon. Having been scratched for the second time in three games, his role has diminished significantly as his production failed to justify his $3.6 million salary. The Oilers, prioritizing both production and cap efficiency, appear ready to move on from Mangiapane, with the Anaheim Ducks, Winnipeg Jets, and Toronto Maple Leafs rumored as potential destinations. The message seems clear: Mangiapane's time in Edmonton is likely over, and the team is keen on protecting their investment while seeking a suitable trade partner.
Frederic's situation is more complex and concerning. Signed to an eight-year deal, the forward has struggled to find his footing in Edmonton. Brought in for his physicality and edge, Frederic has failed to deliver the anticipated disruptive presence. The Oilers seem to be trying to extract the desired performance from Frederic, but there's a growing sense that his game might not align with what the team envisioned. The length of Frederic's contract adds another layer of difficulty to the situation, leaving the Oilers with a potentially long-term problem.
This isn't the first time the Oilers have faced scrutiny for high-priced players underperforming. Derek Ryan, while respected, has been cited as one of the league's highest-paid "benchwarmers," earning $900,000 against the cap while averaging limited ice time and minimal offensive contributions. While Ryan's role was intended to focus on face-offs and defensive play, his lack of playing time raises questions about the value he brings to the team.
The Oilers' struggles highlight the challenges of roster construction and the risks associated with offseason acquisitions. The pressure to contend for a Stanley Cup can lead to hasty decisions, and sometimes, players don't mesh as expected. General Manager Stan Bowman faces the daunting task of navigating the salary cap, balancing present needs with long-term financial stability.
Looking ahead, the Oilers will need to make difficult decisions regarding their roster. Trading Mangiapane seems the most immediate solution, while addressing the Frederic situation will require patience and a clear plan. The team's ability to identify and acquire players who fit their system and contribute effectively will be crucial in their pursuit of a Stanley Cup. The recent struggles serve as a reminder that even the most promising offseason moves can unravel, leaving teams with costly "solutions" watching from the sidelines.
