Carter Hart's potential return to the NHL has become a major talking point, especially after the NHL announced on September 11, 2025, that he would be eligible to sign with a team starting October 15, 2025, and play from December 1, 2025, following his acquittal in a 2018 sexual assault case involving Hockey Canada's World Junior team. However, according to Chris Johnston of The Athletic, Hart is already narrowing down his options, with several teams seemingly out of the running.

Reportedly, Hart wants to find a team where he has a clear shot at a meaningful number of starts and a chance to win. This desire for a fresh start effectively eliminates a return to the Philadelphia Flyers, his former team. Johnston notes that Hart is likely to sign with a U.S.-based team, further reducing the list of potential destinations. This focus on a U.S. team is probably an attempt to avoid the intense scrutiny and backlash expected in the Canadian market after his involvement in the Hockey Canada scandal. The Canadian teams that are reportedly not in the running include the Edmonton Oilers, a team many initially speculated could be a fit, along with other Canadian cities like Calgary, Toronto, and Montreal.

While the Oilers were initially considered a possible destination, the fit wasn't ideal for either side. Hart, originally from Sherwood Park, Alberta, might have found the spotlight in his hometown too intense as he attempts to rebuild his career. Other teams that are potentially not a fit include those with established starting goalies or those not considered strong contenders.

Several teams are rumored to be interested in Hart. Before his name was linked to the 2018 Hockey Canada incident, several teams were already monitoring his situation, waiting for the NHL's decision on his eligibility. It was also reported that at least four organizations were considering offering him a professional tryout (PTO) if he was cleared to return. The Los Angeles Kings, Washington Capitals, and Buffalo Sabres could be potential landing spots.

Despite the green light from the NHL, Hart faces an uphill battle. His performance in the 2023-24 season was statistically subpar, and the nearly two-year absence from the ice raises questions about his readiness. The NHL itself acknowledged that while the players were acquitted, their actions didn't meet the league's expected standards.

Hart is expected to sign a two- or three-year contract. He will likely use the time between October 15 and November 15 to get back into shape, possibly playing a few AHL games before returning to the NHL in early December.