The debate is intensifying: should Matthew Schaefer, the New York Islanders' sensational rookie defenseman, be named to Canada's Olympic roster? The deadline for submitting the final roster for the upcoming Olympics is fast approaching on December 31, 2025. While the initial roster announcements locked in superstars like Sidney Crosby, Nathan MacKinnon, and Connor McDavid, the emergence of Schaefer has thrown a compelling element into the mix.
Schaefer's impact on the Islanders has been undeniable. The 18-year-old has not only secured a regular spot in the lineup but has become a key contributor, averaging significant ice time. As of December 14, 2025, he stands fifth among Canadian defensemen in points with 23, and third in goals with 9. His offensive contributions are further highlighted by his power-play prowess; Schaefer is tied for the most power-play points among Canadian defensemen and leads all NHL defensemen in power-play goals. This is particularly noteworthy considering the Islanders' power play unit is struggling, ranking 25th in the league.
TSN Hockey Analysts Craig Button and Mike Johnson recently included Schaefer in their projected Team Canada roster, pairing him with veteran Drew Doughty. This decision underscores the belief that Schaefer's talent transcends his age and experience. His ability to contribute offensively and log significant minutes makes him a valuable asset, even if deployed as a seventh defenseman.
Adding further fuel to the fire, Schaefer was added to the Olympic drug-testing pool in November, making him officially eligible for selection. This move signaled that Hockey Canada was seriously considering the young defenseman for the Olympic squad. Prior to this, discussions revolved around whether Schaefer would even remain in the NHL or return to the Ontario Hockey League (OHL).
Schaefer's resume boasts a history of success with Canadian squads, including gold medals at the U17 World Hockey Championships, the U18 World Junior Championships, and the Hlinka Gretzky Cup. He also participated in the 2025 IIHF World Junior Hockey Championships. While some argue that his lack of extensive experience might be a drawback, his performance speaks volumes.
Some analysts suggest that even if Schaefer doesn't crack the starting lineup, his presence as a "healthy scratch" could benefit the team. This alludes to the potential for him to learn from the seasoned professionals and be ready to step in if needed, gaining invaluable experience for future international competitions.
Of course, the competition for roster spots is fierce. Canada boasts a wealth of talent on the blue line, including Cale Makar and Evan Bouchard. However, Schaefer's unique blend of offensive skill and defensive responsibility sets him apart. As Ken Morrow, the Islanders Director of Pro Scouting, stated, "I don't know if I've ever seen an 18-year-old come up and have the impact he has".
Ultimately, the decision rests with Team Canada's management. But with the Olympic roster deadline looming, the call for Matthew Schaefer's inclusion is growing louder, supported by his stellar play and the undeniable spark he brings to the ice.
