The Pittsburgh Penguins' promising start to the 2025-26 season is fading, and frustrations are mounting, particularly concerning veteran defenseman Kris Letang. After a 9-4-2 opening, the team has struggled, jeopardizing their playoff hopes and leading to increased scrutiny of key players.
Concerns surrounding Letang's performance are growing within the organization. While his offensive output remains decent with 16 points in 32 games, his overall impact, especially in the defensive zone, has been criticized. Once celebrated as the Penguins' premier defenseman, the 38-year-old's decline is becoming a problem for the team's short and medium-term plans.
According to The Athletic's Josh Yohe, Letang's struggles stem from a decline in athleticism, leading to more frequent mental errors. Previously, his physical abilities could compensate for these lapses, but that's no longer the case. This echoes earlier reports from June 2025, where sources indicated that Letang's playing style had frustrated former head coach Mike Sullivan and assistant coach David Quinn. The coaching staff was reportedly exasperated by his increased mental errors and diminishing physical skills.
Despite the growing concerns, trading Letang appears highly unlikely. He possesses a full no-movement clause, giving him control over any potential trade. Furthermore, his age, health history (including two strokes), and a $6.1 million annual contract for two more seasons make him difficult to move.
A contract buyout is equally improbable. Because Letang was over 35 when he signed his current deal, a buyout would not provide the Penguins with any salary cap relief. General Manager Kyle Dubas also generally disfavors buyouts. While some might expect Letang to retire given his declining performance, reports suggest he wants to continue playing in the NHL beyond his current contract.
So, what options remain for the Penguins? While a trade or buyout seem impossible, the team could try to reduce Letang's minutes or change his role to better suit his current abilities. Another option would be for Letang to accept a trade, but it is believed he prefers to stay in Pittsburgh with Crosby and Malkin.
The situation presents a significant challenge for Dubas and the Penguins. They must navigate the complexities of managing an aging star whose performance is declining while honoring his contract and his contributions to the franchise. Finding a solution that benefits both the team and Letang will be crucial for the Penguins as they strive to return to playoff contention.
