The Toronto Maple Leafs are facing a storm of speculation surrounding the future of their captain, Auston Matthews, with some analysts suggesting a potential trade as early as 2026. This chatter has gained momentum due to the team's struggles this season and Matthews' dip in offensive production compared to his usual dominant pace.
Adding fuel to the fire, Sportsnet writer Ryan Dixon boldly predicted a blockbuster deal that would send Matthews to the San Jose Sharks in exchange for a package centered around Michael Misa, a highly touted prospect. Misa, drafted 2nd overall by the Sharks in 2025, is considered a potential franchise cornerstone.
However, not everyone is ready to jump on the trade bandwagon. TSN analyst Bryan Hayes has firmly planted his flag, urging fans to support Matthews and calling for an end to the trade speculation. Hayes passionately stated, "I would like the debates over the future of Auston Matthews to come to an end…. I don't want to see this guy go anywhere. Like, I don't want to see the end of the Auston Matthews era in Toronto until he's basically ready to retire". Hayes' stance reflects a belief that Matthews remains a vital part of the Maple Leafs' future and should be supported through this challenging period.
While acknowledging that Matthews is dealing with some sort of long-term chronic injury, NHL Network analyst Jackie Redmond also defended Matthews, pointing to franchise missteps and broader team issues as contributing factors to the team's struggles. She dismissed the notion that the Leafs' problems solely rest on Matthews' shoulders, emphasizing the importance of context and questioning the logic of trading away a player of his caliber. Redmond argued that Matthews cares deeply about the sport and wants to be good at it.
The Maple Leafs currently sit outside the playoff picture with a record of 16-15-6, placing them 8th in the Atlantic Division. Matthews, who is in the second year of a four-year, $53 million extension, has recorded 15 goals and 12 assists in 33 games. While still a productive player, this is a decrease from his usual MVP-level seasons.
TSN analyst Dave Feschuk voiced concerns about Matthews' form, noting that he hasn't been carrying the team and his point production is at its lowest per-game pace as a pro. Feschuk questioned whether Matthews has another gear to elevate his game and lead the team.
The revolving door of wingers playing alongside Matthews has also been a challenge. While Matthew Knies has shown flashes of chemistry, consistency has been elusive. The Maple Leafs face a crucial decision: either Matthews rediscovers his dominant form within the current structure, or the team explores external options to bolster their chances.
