The Indian cricket team faces a compelling selection dilemma as they prepare for the upcoming ODI series against New Zealand, with the backup wicketkeeper's role becoming a hotly contested spot. With KL Rahul established as the first-choice wicketkeeper, the focus shifts to who will fill the crucial role of the second wicketkeeper in the squad. The contenders include Ishan Kishan, Rishabh Pant, and the emerging talent, Dhruv Jurel. Each player brings a unique set of skills and recent performances to the table, making the decision a challenging one for the selectors.
Ishan Kishan has been in impressive form, earning him a place in the T20 World Cup squad. He followed up his World Cup selection with a century in Jharkhand's Vijay Hazare Trophy opener, showcasing his intent and reminding the selectors of his capabilities. Kishan's domestic performance includes 607 runs in his last 14 List A innings, averaging 43.35 with two centuries and a fifty. Furthermore, his ability to bat in the middle order and change the game quickly makes him a valuable asset. After the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy final, Kishan stated the need to improve his game constantly to get selected in the national team.
Rishabh Pant, on the other hand, has been part of the ODI team but hasn't had consistent playing time since August 2024. Despite being included in squads, he often found himself on the bench. Pant's List A numbers are similar to Kishan's, with 572 runs in his last 15 innings at an average of 40.85, including one century and four fifties. However, these innings are spread across five years, highlighting his lack of consistent game time. Some reports suggest that Pant might be dropped from the ODI squad for the New Zealand series. Despite his undeniable talent and match-winning potential, Pant's lack of recent opportunities in the ODI format could go against him. Selectors may consider giving Pant a fair run to assess him meaningfully before making a decision.
Dhruv Jurel has emerged as a strong contender with his recent performances in the Vijay Hazare Trophy. Batting at No. 3 for Uttar Pradesh, Jurel has been in red-hot form, scoring 307 runs in three matches, including his maiden List A hundred against Baroda. Jurel's impressive unbeaten 160 off 101 balls showcased his authority and ability to accelerate the scoring rate. This innings, loaded with 15 fours and eight sixes, not only rescued Uttar Pradesh but also demonstrated Jurel's control of the game. Jurel received his maiden ODI call-up for the Australia tour but remained on the bench.
The selection committee, led by Ajit Agarkar, must consider several factors, including current form, role fit, and squad requirements. Kishan offers a left-handed batting option and has been in good form. Pant is a proven match-winner who needs consistent opportunities. Jurel's recent performances have made a strong case for his inclusion. The decision will likely depend on the team's strategy and the composition they are looking for in the middle order. With the T20 World Cup on the horizon, the ODIs provide an opportunity to test players and finalize the squad.
