The ongoing Test series between India and England has been marred by concerns over the quality and behavior of the Dukes ball. Both teams have voiced their frustration with the ball losing its shape and hardness prematurely, impacting bowlers' ability to generate swing and seam movement.

India's concerns have been particularly vocal. In the first Test at Headingley, the Indian team repeatedly requested a ball change, with vice-captain Rishabh Pant expressing his anger when umpires denied the request. Captain Shubman Gill has also publicly criticized the Dukes ball, stating that it becomes soft too early, making it difficult for bowlers to take wickets. Gill was seen in a heated discussion with umpire Sharfuddoula during the third Test at Lord's, requesting a newer ball. During the second day of the third Test, India requested that the second new ball be changed after it went out of shape after only 63 deliveries. The replacement ball was then changed after 48 deliveries. Mohammed Siraj was also seen questioning the umpire about the ball.

England's captain Ben Stokes has also acknowledged the issue, noting that touring teams often face problems with the Dukes ball going soft and losing shape. Stokes even suggested that the rings used to measure the ball's shape might not be compatible with Dukes balls.

The frequent ball changes have disrupted the flow of the game and have become a major talking point throughout the series. Former England seamer Stuart Broad has described the situation as "unacceptable", saying the ball is being changed virtually every innings and stating that "Dukes have a problem, they need to fix it".

Dukes ball manufacturer Dilip Jajodia has responded to the criticism, stating that no cricket ball can be 100% perfect due to the natural raw materials used. He also highlighted that modern bats are more powerful, making it harder for balls to have an equal impact. He added that a cricket ball is supposed to go soft over time, which is why a new ball is given after 80 overs. He also suggested the ICC consider allowing the new ball to be taken between the 60th and 70th over. Jajodia has also said that making a harder ball could risk damaging bats.

Despite the concerns about the ball, the series has been highly competitive, with both teams showcasing their strengths. England successfully chased down a record 371 in the first test at Headingley. However, the ongoing debate surrounding the Dukes ball raises questions about the consistency and fairness of the game. Whether the authorities will intervene and address these concerns remains to be seen.